Collectors Club Board
Guest Expert Forum #8: Vintage Card Grading with Andy Broome of CGC
Vice President of CGC Cards and head sports card grader
All-Member Buy / Sell / Trade
Buy / Sell / Trade welcome here, but use the usual precautions. There is also a Gold-member Forum which includes Buy / Sell / Trade and Gold members can also list Classifieds for a public audience.
Cardhound Vintage 101: Condition Workshop
In order to buy, sell, or trade effectively, a collector needs to be able to accurately assess card condition, especially for raw (ungraded) cards. This quick seminar gives resources and practice activities and even features a "final exam" of sorts. Start by reading Cardhound's Ultimate Vintage Sports Raw Card Condition Guide.
Other helpful resources before getting started are PSA's Grading Standards and SGC's Grading Scale. Ideally, you get good enough at assessing raw cards that if you submit any for grading, you won't be surprised by the results.
Tools / materials to gather include:
- A good LED light or desk lamp. Mine has a built-in magnifier.
- A jeweler's loupe or other magnifier (optional)
- A card centering app or tool
Once you're ready, let's get to work! Scroll down the the Introductions thread first and then work through Activities 1-4 in any order, but save the "Final" for last!
Cardhound Vintage 101: Counterfeit Workshop
Course Overview:
This 5-part course teaches collectors how to identify counterfeit vintage sports cards. Using visual comparisons, physical trait checks, and expert info, you’ll learn how to train your eye—and your instincts—to spot fakes before you get fooled.
Start by reading the Cardhound guide on How to Spot Counterfeit Sports Cards.
Helpful tools include a pile of commons (vintage and modern), a loupe or magnification (a good phone camera will work), and a small black light flashlight is also helpful.
Cardhound Grading Advice
The Cardhound Community is glad to offer free advice regarding the following:
- "Should I grade this card?"
- "What grade would this card receive?"
All members are free to chime in with opinions, and Cardhound Admin (chvadmin) will both monitor advice for accuracy and offer "official" Cardhound opinions.
HOW TO USE:
1. Post just a few cards per submission.
2. Post high-resolution scans or good pictures of front and back. Attach here or link us to a folder.
3. Verbally describe any defects not clearly visible in photos.
Disclaimers: We obviously cannot guarantee any grade or outcome, or that a card has not been altered and therefore is not eligible for a grade at all! All final decisions and outcomes are the responsibility of the card owner / submitter. Grading cards from pictures is less reliable than having a card in hand, and grading is a subjective process. But in general, we understand SGC and PSA grading scales and can help folks make sound decisions about whether grading a certain card is worth the expense.
Guest Expert Forum Archive
- Subforums:
- Guest Expert Forum #7: Card Grading Q&A With Eric Drew (SGC / Boca Card Subs) and Cardhound Matt
- Guest Expert Forum #6: Card Grading, Card Condition Q&A August 5-11 2024
- Guest Expert Forum #5: Auction House Q&A w/ LOTG and Cuban Baseball Auctions June 17-21 2024
- Guest Expert Forum #4: "Vintage Values / Market Discussion" w/ VCP Reps and Ashsh Jai, May 20-24 2024
- Guest Expert Forum #3: "Succeeding on Social Media w/ Vintage" April 29-May 3 2024
- Guest Expert Forum #2: "Living the dream: Making a Living in Sports Cards" w/ Eric Drew, Justin Farber, and Brian Roth, April 16-18 2024
- Guest Expert Forum #1: April 9-11. Talk Vintage Baseball Photography and Painting with Paul Reiferson and Graig Kreindler!